Best way to make Peanut Butter Cookie Sandwiches

Peanut Butter Cookie Sandwiches are easy to make. You simply spread one cookie with peanut butter, top it with another cookie, and then press them together gently. These cookies are best when served cold, but they can also be kept at room temperature or frozen. These delicious treats are great for any occasion. Read on to discover how to make them! This recipe will make the perfect gift for your loved one. You can also try it for yourself.

I can’t believe what I am doing. I am ashamed.
I almost don’t want to tell you, especially after this post.

But here goes…..
I am watching The Bachelor.

I caved in! I wanted to know what my friends were facebooking and tweeting about. I wanted to watch the show that people watch season after season (not to mention there isn’t anything on TV Monday evenings). And, I also wanted to see how funny, catty, and skanky classy the girls are!

The show starts and the bachelor is standing there in a suit and these girls are getting out of limos one by one. They have on formal gowns, which I find silly. Couldn’t you tell more about a person if they are dressed normally? The gals give him a little trinket, note or gift when they step out of their limo which is their own way of saying ‘hello and please keep me around’ because at the end of the episode, only 15 of the 25 girls stayed.

I just have a little bit of advice for these ladies. If you are ever on The Bachelor and want the guy to keep you around, get out of that limo with an apron on and some fresh, baked cookies in your hand. Especially these cookies. He will choose you on the spot!

Peanut Butter Cookie Sandwiches

Peanut Butter Cookie Sandwiches are the perfect snack for a child's birthday or a treat for a friend. They are easy to make and a perfect gift. Mix together the ingredients for the filling. Use a hand mixer to make it extra creamy. Place one cookie on top of the other and press down. This sweet treat is the perfect treat to give as a gift! The best part is that you can make the cookies ahead of time and freeze them.
Prep Time 15 mins
Cook Time 15 mins
Total Time 30 mins
Course Dessert, Snack
Cuisine American
Servings 4 servings
Calories 53 kcal


  • Bake cookies according to directions (except roll in 20 small balls rather than 12.)
  • When cool, spread dark chocolate spread (or melted chocolate) on backside of one cookie, then sandwich with another cookie.



These cookie sandwiches are great! This is my go-to peanut butter cookie recipe since I always have peanut butter, sugar and an egg on hand. Not to mention they are delicious, soft (and gluten free if that matters to you!) Sometimes I like to add a pinch of salt, and sometimes I add a tsp of baking soda for a lighter cookie. These cookies aren't too sweet, but more creamy, decadent and salty.
Keyword cookie sandwich

Tips and Tricks

Peanut Butter Cookie Sandwiches (Just like Nutter Butters!) - Sally's  Baking Addiction

You can use different tools to spread the buttercream. A piping tip is the easiest to use. An offset spatula will work the best for spreading the filling. If you don’t have any of these tools, you can also use the back of a spoon. Just be sure to keep the dough covered. The buttercream will spread as you add the top cookie. Once the sandwich is formed, add the jelly or chocolate chips to the middle.

You can make these cookies dairy-free if you like. The filling recipe calls for milk, but you can substitute non-dairy milk. After mixing the ingredients, wrap the cookie dough tightly. The dough should be room temperature and smooth before it is baked. You can store the finished cookie at room temperature for several days. You can freeze the balls of dough before assembling it. These cookies can also be made in advance and stored for several days.

READ MORE  Basic way to make Honey Roasted Almonds easy at home

The filling is easy to make. You can either use peanut butter, honey, or any other flavor you like. Just make sure that you use a dairy-free milk. If you do not have dairy-free milk, you can use non-dairy milk instead. If you prefer, you can also make the peanut butter cookies gluten-free way by making them with flourless chocolate chip. And if you don’t want to stick to a particular recipe, you can add another type of filling, such as a candy bar, or a candies.

Peanut butter and chocolate are the classic pairing. It’s not hard to make them dairy-free, but you can try other types of fillings as well. For instance, you can combine peanut butter and chocolate chips in a flourless chocolate chip cookie and assemble it as a sandwich. A delicious and simple treat! A perfect combination for any occasion! Once you’ve made your sandwich cookies, you can enjoy them at any time. You can even freeze them if you’d like.

When making peanut butter cookie sandwiches, you’ll want to combine the ingredients for the filling. Incorporate the nuts and chocolate chips. You can also add chocolate chips and jelly. Then, place your sandwich cookies on a baking sheet. Once they’re done baking, you can spread the peanut butter frosting on them and top them with a second cookie. If you’d like, you can freeze the leftovers in the freezer for later.

If you’re vegan, you can use almond butter instead of peanut butter. Alternatively, you can use other types of fillings as well. You’ll have no problem making these tasty desserts if you’re allergic to peanuts. If you’re looking for an easy recipe to impress friends and family, try this delicious treat. You’ll be glad you did. The filling is the most important part of these cookies.

READ MORE  Berry Pie Bars… and Pots! - Easy homemade recipe

The filling is an essential part of the sandwich. You’ll need to mix a mixture of peanut butter, powdered sugar, and honey to form a creamy filling. Then, you can pipe the mixture on the cookie, or sandwich the two together. A peanut butter cookie sandwich is a delicious treat for any time of day! The combination of peanut butter and jelly is timeless and has many health benefits.

Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies with Peanut Butter Chocolate Ganache:  #CreativeCookieExchange - The Spiced Life